Difference between revisions of "Nagisa Renge/Personality"

By Nagisa's reckoning, in an objective universe, there is no such thing as "right" or "wrong." The universe simply is, and people and the things and beings around oneself simply are as well. For that reason, life and death are not inherently "good" or "bad," which are just extreme extensions of the concepts of "right" and "wrong." What makes an impression on Nagisa is that a person lives passionately--she is most impressed by those people who truly believe in something and live their lives doing everything to further that end. To her, living life as if floating through it, not caring about what happens, being oblivious and being thoughtless are... well, defense mechanisms, but by Nagisa's view, unhealthy ones. These, along with the people who actively take their life for granted and complain about relatively small things, are the types of people she will typically attack after she's talked with them enough, though she'll also attack those who are striving for something, but don't understand why. To help these people is, in Nagisa's view, her calling--her way of sharing her insight and understanding, in the true style of the Judgment Arcana, even if her methods are rather warped by conventional ways of thinking.

It makes sense to her. She's suffered a lot during her life, but that eventually brought her to a true understanding and acceptance of the universe around her. Ergo, the best thing she can do is bring others to an understanding of the fragility that made life so beautiful, and in knowing that fragility, make them understand that no matter how big their problems and worries might seem, it won't be permanent. This brought Nagisa to the logical (to her) conclusion that if people were brought to the verge of death, but not quite pushed off, they would appreciate the wonderful parts in their lives, no matter how small it might be. As such, she takes it upon herself to not simply sit back and wait to be loved, but to bring people to the realization of the love they already had in their lives by... attempting to kill them. Nagisa's near-death experience had put lots of things into perspective for her, including what was truly important, so obviously this is the best thing she could possibly do for anyone else. Compared to the imminent prospect of getting brutally knifed to death, their problems really aren't that bad, that there is something worthwhile in living that makes it worth struggling on. In a way, this is because Nagisa wants to affirm for herself that this is so--to have others acknowledge the way she lives by responding (what she views as) positively to her attempts to teaching them this. This resurrection and redemption, core concepts of the Judgment Arcanum, are what define Nagisa as a person now, and so part of her needs others to acknowledge it as well. That said, Nagisa recognizes that, even if they DO respond positively to nearly dying, they won't necessarily respond well to her as the catalyst of this. She can accept this, even if it makes her lonely; she bears no hatred for the Kirijo Group for experimenting on her when she was younger, thus shortening her life, so it's her view that someone should be okay with what she does to try to enrich the lives of others in her own particular, bloody way. It doesn't quite occur to her that most people won't like someone who tries to stab them--she knows it, but can't actually quite grok it.

Her least favorite kind of person, conversely, is the kind that doesn't acknowledge what they have in favor of focusing on the things that they're not happy about (i.e., self-entitled whiners)--these are the ones where Nagisa will attack them without a dialogue first, where a part of Nagisa doesn't mind if she goes a little too far and kills them outright. It *is* important to Nagisa to talk to people first, after all; her time growing up homeless in Sumaru taught her that talking to people can show you so much about who they are. Perhaps, in their next life, they'll understand better what a gift it is. Nagisa has her own biases, though, and as poor people often do, she doesn't really grok the concept of having a materially fulfilling life but an emotionally miserable one. Nagisa typically prefers not to finish off her victims, but someone who seems to her like they aren't reacting to life and the will to live even after being attacked aren't, in her opinion, worth allowing to live. When she kills someone (or anything, really), she also always watches them die unless circumstances forbid it. Because Nagisa values living, she watches very carefully when she kills someone or something, to remind herself that the same could happen to her at any time. To Nagisa, "living" is not the same as "life." Anyone can sleep and breathe and eat and do the other necessary functions for a day-to-day existence, but not many are capable of really throwing themselves into what they do, to look at the world with eyes that renew themselves every minute. Memento mori--taking a good at death wherever it arises, be it at her hand or not--is how she keeps herself from forgetting this.

In spite of all that, though, Nagisa doesn't believe in unnecessary cruelty. By her view, her attempted murders are (usually) done out of necessity. Suffering is needed to bring perspective, but she rarely gets any particular joy out of hurting others. If anything, she gets joy out of people understanding as a result of the suffering she brings them. On a certain level, she knows what she's doing to them is a bad thing, but so powerfully did her own experience affect her that she thinks it's okay. Although she was unhappy and wished it had never happened when she was suffering in the streets of Sumaru after the Kirijo Group threw her away, she understands now that it was necessary to get to the point where she is now. Ergo, even if people (quite reasonably) hate her for trying to kill them, she meets these reactions with a certain sad acceptance. Someone who tries to kill her back, not only does she not begrudge their efforts, she actually encourages them, because in her view, fighting for one's life means that one values it.

She is honest and direct--not necessarily cruel with her words but ironically not always understanding what she says might hurt someone. She calls things as she sees them, and she also answers honestly (though not necessarily completely) when asked questions. She's unafraid of speaking her own mind, as well. This means she is poor at keeping secrets unless told specifically to keep a secret, at which point she'll apologetically refuse to talk about the matter, but even then, the savvy interrogator could easily glean clues off of her body language. Because Nagisa is straightforward, she is easy to get information off of (ask her a direct question and she will answer it honestly), but difficult to manipulate in that special hard-to-fool way dummies can sometimes be. At the same time, she can't really manipulate others--she lacks the ability to do so, and can often miss subtle cues from those around her. She's also slow to make decisions on something or decide what she thinks of someone, but once she has, it's nearly impossible for her to shake her from that.

For the aforementioned reasons, Nagisa tends to appear innocent, even when she's trying to kill someone. Her frail, childish appearance helps with this. Some people will scorn her, because nobody is loved by all, but she has this air of needing to be protected, like a sheltered little sister who hasn't yet learned how to deal with other people. Nagisa can be and on the whole is friendly, tending towards the same sweet personality she had when she was younger, if more mellow and less with the desperation to please she once had. This is because she doesn't allow things like "propriety" and "shame" to color her reactions to and interactions with other people. This also means she is free to enjoy things that other people might find too embarrassing to admit to without feeling any of the social pressure, and likewise that she doesn't judge others based on normal societal criteria. Since life has no intrinsic meaning, either positive or negative, Nagisa feels no need to be embarrassed that she's "too old" for finding simple joy in nature and discovery, or that playing in the dirt is "for boys." It no longer even occurs to her to be embarrassed, and would be quite nonplussed to hear it suggested otherwise, either for herself or for others. Oh, Kanji is a big tough dude who likes to sew--it's so impressive that he has something he can be passionate about! Passion and a will to live and experience life are the things that Nagisa cares about. Everything else is mostly meaningless to her.

Indeed, she views herself and the entire world as insignificant in the cosmic sense, but finds this liberating rather than depressing. If, in the big picture, all things are meaningless, then one is free to do what matters to oneself without worrying about the others around oneself. Even Nyx and the Fall does not matter especially much to her in and of themselves, but what they represent. She participates in bringing it about because of two reasons: one, she's eager to see the world just before its demise, to see how beautiful it would appear when all people are moments away from becoming the Lost, how beautiful all substance is before being eaten up by oblivion; and two, she wants to see how beautifully people struggle to try to stop this entropy. If they can't or don't, then it's for the best that the world ends, so that it may somehow start anew. If they do stop it, then it is an affirmation of the will to live against all odds, and reinforces Nagisa's belief that suffering is what brings out the worthiest parts of a human being. Were she on the top floor of Tartarus the midnight of January 31st, she would be watching not the arrival of Nyx and the fall of the moon, but the reactions of a) the other people around her, and b) the people out in the city who have just awakened to the Dark Hour. To Nagisa, these are the things that have meaning, that make her feel as if she's still a human being.

That last part is important. Nagisa has trouble holding onto her humanity. This is a thing that actually bothers her. When she really gets down to it, she does not feel as if she truly is a part of the human race, but is someone watching from in the middle of a crowded street as people flow like a river past her. Though she's unafraid of death or dying in and of themselves, deep down, she is afraid of dying alone and forgotten, or of getting eaten by Shadows/becoming one of the Lost (while everyone else is still human; the coming of Nyx is an equalizer in the same way Death is, and so /that/ doesn't bother her), just as she was before her Persona fully awakened. It at least doesn't matter to her if she is ever important in a big, cosmic sense; she just, in her heart of hearts, wants to truly matter to at least one other person. She loves her own Persona deeply, seeing Miao Shan as a symbol of overcoming all the suffering she's faced and being stronger and gentler for it, but one cannot live loving and being loved by oneself alone. This is the big reason why she hangs out with Strega--as people who have undergone the same experiences at her, even if their way of viewing the world is different, Nagisa feels as if she's the closest to Takaya, Jin and Chidori as anyone else in the world. This is also the big thing that might ever cause her to have doubt in her attempts to save people by brutalizing them, or even cause a breakdown in her paradigm--that even if suffering might bring them understanding, all it might cause in the end is to draw others' hatred as she fails to do anything of meaning.

It's this contradiction that allows Nagisa to be all right with the Revenge Request and other less savory things that Strega does. The Revenge Request is particularly important, though. Tomomi is someone Nagisa's not especially fond of, but for Takaya's sake, she will work with her and the other members of Strega. Revenge Request is something that Takaya specifically is going--not to help people understand themselves, but simply killing people for money. Something about this jives Nagisa as being off, but just as the darker aspect of Judgment means that one may be deluding oneself, Nagisa convinces herself that what Takaya is doing is genuinely well-meant, and that his message of the Fall is the same thing as what she's trying to do, just on a greater scale. As a result, she can sometimes completely fail to acknowledge some of the things Takaya might say that would tell a more discerning individual that, nope, Takaya hates humanity and just wants the world to end. Nagisa does what she does out of a sense of love--most of the time, and twisted by the values of much of modern society--but she cannot or will not see that this is not the case for Takaya and the other members of Strega, because she wants to believe that, in being united in a single goal, they will love her too. She has patience now for the people she tries to save, thus why she can accept that they might not like her for doing what she must, but as time grinds on and she grows closer to death unloved, her resolve may eventually break. Social Links, as ever, are key.